Your Guide to the Athens, Ohio, Food Scene: 13 Places You Have to Try on Court Street

Food in Athens, Ohio, is a foodie’s paradise! With its vibrant and exciting food scene on Court Street alone, you can find anything from classic American food to international dishes. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or an intimate dinner date, there are plenty of options in the area. Here are 13 food places you have to try.

Why Court Street?

Ask any Ohio University student what they love most about Athens, and they’ll probably mention the food scene on Court Street.  First, it’s all within walking distance from campus and most off-campus housing.

When you’re juggling classes, studying, and a social life, convenience is everything. You can grab a coffee on your way to a morning lecture, meet friends for lunch, or snag a late-night slice of pizza without ever needing a car. Plus, the variety is unmatched. You’ll find local staples that have been serving Bobcats for decades.

Court Street is the reliable, go-to destination for Athens, Ohio, food at any time of day.

1. Court Street Coffee

Serving up specialty coffee drinks and baked goods, Court Street Coffee is the perfect spot for a quick caffeine pick-me-up or light breakfast. Court Street Coffee is right in front of Ohio University, making it an ideal spot for students and locals.

• Why We Love It: A cozy, relaxed atmosphere with friendly staff and delicious coffee options.
• Location: 67 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701

2. Bagel Street Deli

Indulge in an unforgettable bagel experience from this one-of-a-kind Court Street deli, which offers a variety of signature bagel sandwiches that will redefine your perception of the humble breakfast staple.

• Why We Love It: A seemingly endless menu, fast service, and a classic Athens vibe.
• Location: 27 S Court St., Athens, OH 45701.

3. Casa Nueva

Bringing a taste of Latin American food to Athens, Casa Nueva offers an eclectic range of Mexican-style dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for tacos or fajitas, you can count on Casa Nueva to have something that will satisfy your cravings.

• Why We Love It: Delicious, locally-sourced food, a vibrant atmosphere, and great live entertainment.
• Location: 6 W State St., Athens, OH 45701.

4. Big Mamma’s Burritos

Another favorite among students is a hearty burrito from Big Mamma’s Burritos. This food spot is a must-try for those late-night burrito fanatics. Big Mamma’s will tantalize your taste buds with a variety of mouthwatering burrito delicacies, from the classic chipotle ranch to their signature Ulti-Mamma.

• Why We Love It: Huge portions, customizable burritos, and perfect for a late-night craving.
• Location: 10 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701

5. HangOverEasy

After a fun-filled evening of bar hopping on Court Street, if you’re looking for food in Athens, Ohio, that will turn your “hangover” into a good mood, then HangOverEasy is the place to go. They serve up classic American breakfast with just the right amount of flavor and spice.

• Why We Love It: The relaxed atmosphere and friendly service make this the perfect spot to catch up with friends over a delicious breakfast.
• Location: 18 N Court St, Athens, OH 45701

6. Fluff Bakery

Satisfy your sweet tooth and savory cravings at Fluff Bakery with its delectable assortment of desserts and lunch options—truly the best of both worlds! Make sure to hit this spot before 3 pm for lunch before they close.

• Why We Love It: Fluff Bakery is known for its creative and unique flavor combinations, like their popular “Peanut Butter & Jelly” cupcake or the “S’mores Dip” dessert.
• Location: 8 N Court St, Athens, OH 45701

7. GoodFella’s Pizza

With its fresh, hot pizzas, GoodFella’s Pizza is the perfect spot to hang out with friends. Order a whole pizza to share or grab a slice when you’re on the go. The pizza here will leave you feeling satisfied without emptying your wallet!

• Why We Love It: Giant slices, great value, and open late.
• Location: 6 W Union St, Athens, OH 45701

8. Mr. Hibachi Japanese Grill and Sushi

For food in Athens, Ohio, that is both flavorful and beautiful, Mr. Hibachi Japanese Grill and Sushi will not disappoint. With its full menu of traditional sushi dishes, flavor-packed hibachi entrees, and yummy appetizers, you can’t go wrong with this spot.

• Why We Love It: Not only is the food delicious, but the presentation is top-notch. The chefs put on a dazzling show as they cook your meal right in front of you.
• Location: 19 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701

9. Ginger Asian Kitchen

Ginger Asian Kitchen takes you on a food journey and transports your taste buds to the streets of Japan and China. From classic dishes like poke and sushi to lo mein and Chinese-style dumplings, Ginger Asian Kitchen is sure to satisfy any food craving.

• Why We Love It: Fresh ingredients, a wide variety of Asian dishes, and generous portions.
• Location: 28 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701

10. Whit’s Frozen Custard

No list of food in Athens, Ohio, is complete without mentioning Whit’s Frozen Custard. Enjoy a sweet, creamy, and delicious frozen custard treat that will take your taste buds to heaven! This frozen treat is sure to freshen up your night and put a smile on everyone’s face.

• Why We Love It: Whit’s Frozen Custard is the perfect dessert spot for any occasion, whether it’s a hot summer day or a chilly winter evening. And with rotating flavors of the week, there’s always something new to try!
• Location: 49 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701

11: O’Betty’s Red Hot

O’Betty’s is not your average hot dog stand. This tiny shop packs a big punch with its gourmet hot dogs and quirky, burlesque-themed decor. It’s a must-visit for a quick, fun, and flavorful bite. Don’t forget to check out the hot dog museum in the back!

• Why We Love It: Unique hot dog creations, fun atmosphere, and a one-of-a-kind experience.
• Location: 15 W State St, Athens, OH 45701

12: Bubbles Tea & Juice Company

Bubbles Tea & Juice Company is a must-visit for any tea lover in the Athens area. This cozy shop offers a wide variety of bubble teas, smoothies, and fresh juices to satisfy your cravings. Each drink is made with high-quality ingredients and bursting with flavor.

• Why We Love It: The perfect spot for a refreshing and healthy drink.
• Location: 19 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701

13: Kiser’s Barbeque

Kiser’s Barbeque is a must-visit for any meat lover in the Athens area, even though it’s not technically on Court Street. This family-owned and operated restaurant has been serving up mouth-watering barbecue since 1990. Their meats are slow-smoked over hickory wood for hours, resulting in tender and flavorful dishes.

• Why We Love It: The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make this a great spot for a casual lunch or dinner with friends.
• Location: 355 E State St, Athens, OH 45701

Live Close to the Best Food Scene with Wharton Rentals

If you’re looking for Athens, Ohio rentals, there’s no better place to look than Wharton Rentals. With houses and apartments close to all of these food spots and many more, you’ll be able to enjoy the best food in Athens, Ohio, just by walking down the block.

Plus, Wharton Rentals offers a variety of property types at different price points, so there’s something for everyone. Live close to the food scene and Athens, Ohio rentals with Wharton Rentals!